Case Updates
At NLRB's request, D.C. Circuit dismisses appeal
December 09, 2013
In an order dated 2/19/2013, the D.C. Court removed this case from the oral argument calendar and held it in abeyance per Noel Canning.
Previously, on 5/17/2012, the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia ruled that the ambush election rule is invalid “because no quorum ever existed for the pivotal vote in question.” Accordingly, the court granted the Chamber's motion for summary judgment and denied the defendant's motion.
Subsequently, the court rejected the NLRB’s motion to amend its 5/17/2012 judgment that the NLRB’s ambush election rule was invalid because it was adopted without a quorum. On 7/272012 the court ruled that the NLRB’s “new evidence” that a third board member was present in the NLRB’s electronic voting room when the rule was adopted was insufficient to prove that the court’s prior decision was a “clear error.” As a result, the ambush election rule is still invalid, and the NLRB’s agreement not to try to enforce the rule against employers is still in effect.
On 12/9/2013, the NLRB asked the D.C. Circuit to dismiss the appeal.
U.S. Chamber urges federal appeals court to invalidate NLRB's ambush election rule in light of unconstitutional recess appointments
December 20, 2011
The U.S. Chamber has urged the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit to uphold a decision of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia that ruled that the Ambush Election Rule is invalid “because no quorum ever existed for the pivotal vote in question.”
In addition to the D.C. District Court's ruling that Member Brian Hayes did not participate in the vote, depriving the Board of a quorum, the U.S. Chamber subsequently filed a 28(j) letter with the D.C. Circuit arguing that under the court's recent decision in Noel Canning v. NLRB, the recess appointment of Member Craig Becker was invalid, and therefore, the Board would not have had a lawful quorum to promulgate the rule even if Member Hayes had participated in the vote.
The Ambush Election Rule, if left to stand, would lead to ‘drive-by’ accelerated union elections, which would deprive employers of the opportunity to rebut union propaganda. As a result, unionizing would become much easier because employees would only hear the unions’ arguments in favor of unionizing, without getting full information on the costs of unionizing to employees and employers alike.
NLRB opening brief filed with the DC Circuit on 11/16/12. NCLC's reply brief filed 12/31/12. Board's Reply filed 1/16/13.
Complaint filed 12/20/2011. Amended complaint filed 2/3/2012. Cross-motions for summary judgment filed 2/3/2012. Decided 5/14/2012. NLRB's Motion to Amend the Judgment filed 6/11/12. Plaintiffs' Response to NLRB's Motion to Amend Judgment filed 6/27/12. NLRB's reply filed 7/9/12. Motion to Amend Rejected 7/27/12. NLRB filed Notice of Appeal on 8/7/12.
Chamber 28j letter filed 1/30/12. Case removed from oral argument calendar and held in abeyance (2/19/13).
Stipulation of Voluntary Dismissal filed 12/9/13.
Case Documents
- NLRB Opening Brief - Chamber of Commerce v. NLRB (D.C. Circuit).pdf
- Chamber of Commerce, et al. v. NLRB (Ambush Election Rule) Complaint).pdf
- NLRB Final Ambush Election Rule.pdf
- Chamber of Commerce, et al. v. NLRB (Amended Complaint).pdf
- Chamber of Commerce, et al. v. NLRB (Plaintiffs' Memo in Support of MSJ).pdf
- Chamber of Commerce, et al. v. NLRB (Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment).pdf
- Chamber of Commerce, et al. v. NLRB (Plaintiffs' Proposed Order).pdf
- Chamber of Commerce, et al. v. NLRB (Board's Final Ambush Election Rule Resolution).pdf
- Chamber of Commerce, et al. v. NLRB (Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment).pdf
- Chamber of Commerce, et al. v. NLRB (Defendant's Memo in Support of MSJ).pdf
- Chamber of Commerce, et al. v. NLRB (Proposed Amicus Brief - American Hospital Association, et al.).pdf
- Chamber of Commerce, et al. v. NLRB (Defendant's Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgement).pdf
- Chamber of Commerce, et al. v. NLRB (Reply in Support of Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgement).pdf
- Chamber of Commerce, et al. v. NLRB (Decision).pdf
- NLRB memorandum to alter judgment.pdf
- NLRB Affidavit.pdf
- Opposition to Rule 59(e).pdf
- Chamber of Commerce v. NLRB Board Reply to Rule 59(e) motion.pdf
- Chamber of Commerce, et al. v. National Labor Relations Board (Court Decision Denying NLRB Motion to Amend Judgment).pdf
- Appellees Brief -- Chamber of Commerce et al. v. NLRB (D.C. Circuit).pdf
- NLRB Reply Brief -- Chamber of Commerce v. NLRB (D.C. Circuit).pdf
- Appellants 28j Letter Regarding Noel Canning -- Chamber, et. al. v. NLRB (Ambush Election Rule) (DC Circuit).pdf
- D.C. Circuit Order removing from calendar and holding in abeyance.pdf
- Stipulation of Dismissal -- Chamber of Commerce, et al. v NLRB (D.C. Circuit).pdf